Order Of The Phoenix Vs Half Blood Prince Video Game

[Guest]

[JHYLER]

So what does everyone think?

[lemonlemonuk]

Ooh, what a hard question.

in HBP there is more of the castle to explore and the graphics are better however Nearly-Headless Nick is your guide and can get quite annoying. In OOTP there are extra features which are good and you have a map to look at.

What made me vote HBP was the extra minigames like Potions and Quidditch and Dueling. They are really good!

If only there was a "Cant Decide!" tick box!!!!

I really hope they go back over the first two games and re-do them in the style of these last two games! The graphics in PS and COS are awefull! They would make so much more money as everyone would buy them for their wii/ps3!

[stoney]

I would have to say OOTP.
In fact i'm re-playing the game at the moment because i finished HBP within a matter of a few hours.
The castle and grounds have been expanded for HBP so there is more space to roam around and the graphics are indeed better.

The potions and Dueling and Quidditch are fun to begin with but even they can get repetative after a while and i much prefer the map and footprints method for OOTP than having Nick as the guide.

I know there was no Quidditch in OOTP but there was a bit of Dueling and there was so much more to do with finding all the DA members and performing tasks to get them to the Room of Requirement, the mini tasks for all the teachers and then completing all the extras to get 100% for each room or part of the castle.

I really enjoyed playing the different Gobstones games too and i wish they had included these in HBP but alas not.

So it's definitely OOTP for me